Nightline: A World Without Men?

Last night Nightline aired this report on the sperm-from-stem-cell news:

A World Without Men?  Scientists create human sperm from stem cells.  Will men soon be irrelevant?

I’m glad they aren’t shy about focusing more on the same-sex conception angle rather than the infertility angle, as some stories did. But I wish they weren’t so sensationalistic and jocular about it, as if the only issue was just male insecurity and silly worries about men no longer existing. They should have addressed the costs and implications of allowing same-sex conception and not implied the only issue was who would take out the trash. And they shouldn’t have treated it as inevitable. That’s especially disappointing because in England, where this report seems to have been produced, same-sex conception and genetic engineering are already prohibited, and Parliament is debating whether to change the ban to allow the use of stem cell derived gametes, and it looks like they will allow it for infertility but not same-sex conception. They could have been informative, instead of trying to make an entertaining Doctor Who episode (which is impossible, but I digress). Oh well.

But it’s still a very provocative report that should get people talking, and it’s great to see this story is finally breaking through the media blackout and starting to reach the American public.

crossposted at eggandsperm blog

About John Howard